When One Door Closes, Another Opens… Maybe. Fourth Circuit Holds That Surcharge Is Not Equitable Relief Available Under ERISA But Paves the way for Unjust Enrichment Claims

In an ERISA case for wrongful denial of health insurance benefits, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit addressed when a plaintiff may recover monetary relief under §§ 502(a)(1)(B) and (a)(3). The Fourth Circuit unsurprisingly held that ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) limits recovery to benefits due under the terms of a plan, and a plaintiff cannot recover the cost of a denied surgery because the cost is not a “benefit” due; coverage for the cost, and payment to the provider, is the benefit. Unless a plaintiff pays the bill first, the plaintiff cannot recover the cost from an insurer.

The court’s discussion of the § 502(a)(3) claim was not so straight-forward, however, and ultimately much more important. The Fourth Circuit held that § 502(a)(3), which expressly permits only “appropriate equitable relief,” does allow some forms of monetary relief (traditionally thought of as legal, and not equitable), but prohibits others.